Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Pita Melt
Crab Cakes (5 Mini)
Bottled Water
Iced Coffee
About
Athens Square Cafe
Welcome to Athens Square Cafe, a cozy gem nestled in East Northport, NY, at 517 Larkfield Rd. This charming establishment offers a taste of Greece that has captured the hearts of locals and families for over 15 years. The heart and soul of Athens Square Cafe is its dedicated owner, who not only prepares each dish with love but also ensures that every guest feels like part of the family.
From the moment you step through the door, you're enveloped in the warm ambiance of this intimate dining space. While it may be small, the flavors served at Athens Square Cafe are anything but minor. Many customers, including the long-time patron Liam Kilroy, rave about the consistently outstanding meals that keep them coming back. Culinary delights here range from tender chicken gyros to exceptionally fresh Greek salads, prepared with the utmost care.
Debbie Donahue highlights the impeccable quality of the chicken, which is always tender and bursting with flavor, complemented by the freshest ingredients in their Greek salads. The café shines a spotlight on classic Greek dishes like lamb chops, yogurt sauce, and pork souvlaki. Each plate tells a story, and food enthusiasts can’t help but rave about the deliciousness of these offerings. Ozzie Ferrer, another loyal customer, emphasizes how every bite feels like a celebration of Greek cuisine.
Service at Athens Square Cafe adds to the overall dining experience, as seen in Owen Smith's and R Nine's remarks regarding the friendly and professional staff. Attentive waitresses enhance your meal, ensuring that your experience is memorable. The café manages to strike the perfect balance in providing excellent food at decent prices, making it a winning choice for those seeking a flavorful journey to Greece without leaving New York.
If you have yet to experience Athens Square Cafe, it's time to make it your new go-to spot for authentic Greek fare. One visit will transform your understanding of Greek cuisine, and you'll likely find yourself returning for more delicious, homemade flavors!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Very small dining area but the food is very good. Never had a bad meal here my family and I have been coming to the Athens square cafe for 15 years now. The owner is always in the back cooking food and is very passionate about his business but is never shy about coming out to say hello and great you. Throughout the years there have been good and bad waitresses but the owner and the food is what keeps us coming back he truly makes you feel like part of the family. ”
“ Solid choice for Greek food. The food and service are great. ”
“ This is the best place in northport-east northport to get greek salad. The chicken was so tender not tuff or like bubble gum the salad was excellent even the tomatoes. We just happened to try it after a long time. So glad we did. This will be our new place for the best Greek food. ”
“ Frequent this place and it never disappoints. The food is excellent. Love the chicken gyro. Prices are decent overall and the staff are pleasant. ”
“ Very delicious Greek food, the Greek salad, yogurt sauce, the lamb chops, the lemon soup pitas, grilled chicken on the Greek salad and pork souvlaki All very yummylicious Our waitress very professional also and nice We will be back Our new go to Greek restaurant to eat Weezie ”
“ Always good food here! The chef and staff were super! ”
“ HIGHLY recommend for catering. They were so kind, communicative, and efficient in catering my mom’s birthday. The food was delicious and everyone at the party was raving about it. I will 100% be using Athens Square again for my catering needs. ”
“ This restaurant is absolutely AMAZING!!! Our server John was so professional, great manners, and so down-to-earth. The prices are great and the quality of the food is truly off the hook! Please come visit my buddy John, (server)! Awesome job Athens Square Cafe! ”